Memo to Fr. Thomas Reese...about his memo to bishops. You are not a magisterium unto yourself.
You might ask if the US Bishops care about memos such as this. I answer with a question - do you think the Pope is a Jedi Knight? I didn't think so. But, there are Catholics who care about these kind of opinions, and thus he (and others like him) need to be answered.
The errors in his memo are legion, so I will let others fisk his argument. Here is one from CMR and another from Fr. Z.